You are currently viewing Top 5 Reasons Why India Is Not in G7 Countries

Top 5 Reasons Why India Is Not in G7 Countries

The Group of Seven (G7) is an influential and exclusive club of advanced economies, involving the United States, United Kingdom, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, and Japan. The G7 serves as a platform for discussions on global economic policies, security, and a range of international challenges. 

Members of G7 countries share historical, economic, and political bonds. The absence of India, one of the world’s largest and fastest-growing economies, from the G7 has raised concerns and discussions about representation, power dynamics, and global governance. 

Delve into the key factors behind India’s exclusion, the implications for both parties, and potential pathways that could lead to India’s greater involvement in the G7.

Also Read: Why China Is Not Yet a Superpower?

Historical Context and Evolution of the G7

The origins of the G7 can be traced back to the 1970s when a series of economic crises prompted leaders from the United States, France, West Germany, the United Kingdom, Italy, and Japan to convene and discuss strategies for economic stability and development. 

Over the years, the group expanded its focus to broader geopolitical issues, creating a platform for major economies to address global challenges.

Several Factors Behind India’s Absence From the G7

India’s absence from the G7 has been a subject of debate, especially as the country’s economic significance and diplomatic influence continue to grow. There are multiple factors behind the exclusion of India from G7. 

  • Economic Dynamics 
  • Non-Aligned Movement Legacy
  • Global Power Shifts
  • Strategic Relations
  • Historical Tensions and Priorities

1) Economic Dynamics

Historically, the G7 was involved with advanced economies with significant industrial power and technological advancements. India, although rapidly developing, has a lower per capita income and faces socio-economic challenges that set it apart from the G7 member states. While India’s economy is one of the largest in the world, its development trajectory differs from other G7 countries.  

2) Non-Aligned Movement Legacy 

During the Cold War, India was a prominent member of the Non-Aligned Movement, which sought to maintain distance from the superpower rivalry between the United States and the Soviet Union.

This stance has shaped India’s approach to multilateral forums and alliances. India’s historical commitment to non-alignment movement and its preference for strategic independence have led to a measured approach to aligning with Western countries.

3) Global Power Shifts

The G7 was founded during a period of relatively stable global power distribution. The rise of emerging economies like India, China, Brazil, and others has shifted the global landscape, necessitating discussions about the inclusion of these nations in influential international bodies. As the world experiences a multipolar shift, the exclusion of significant economies weakens the legitimacy of the G7 as a global forum.

4) Strategic Relations

India values its strategic relations with other countries and has maintained a diverse range of international partnerships. The stance of independent foreign policy might make it less inclined to align closely with any specific bloc, including the G7. India’s foreign policy approach of “multi-alignment” involves expanding relationships with multiple major powers and maintaining an independent stance on global issues.

5) Historical Tensions and Priorities

India has often focused on regional dynamics, such as its relationship with neighbouring countries and its role in regional organisations like SAARC (South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation) and ASEAN (Association for Southeast Asian Nations). 

Five Implications of India’s Absence for G7 Countries 

The exclusion of India from the G7 countries carries significant implications so here we elaborate five important implications of india’s absence

1. Limited Innovations

The G7 discussions could suffer from a lack of diverse viewpoints without India’s representation. India’s unique insights into challenges like poverty alleviation, sustainable development, and climate change could enrich the group’s thought process. Given India’s experience with addressing a range of developmental challenges, its absence limits the exchange of best practices and innovative solutions.

2. Missed Economic Opportunities

India’s booming economy presents profitable trade and investment opportunities. Its exclusion from G7 discussions might lead to missed avenues for economic cooperation and growth. Engaging India in economic discussions could benefit both sides by promoting collaboration in sectors such as technology, energy, and manufacturing.

3. Geopolitical Imbalance

In a rapidly changing geopolitical landscape, India’s absence could contribute to imbalances in power dynamics. This could potentially hamper the effectiveness and relevance of the G7 in addressing global challenges. As a regional power with influence in South Asia and the Indian Ocean, India’s participation would contribute to a more balanced representation of global interests.

4. Regional Impacts 

India’s exclusion could limit the G7’s influence in South Asia, a region of critical geopolitical importance. Collaborative efforts to address issues like terrorism, conflict resolution, and sustainable development might be less effective without India’s involvement. India’s absence might also hinder coordinated efforts to promote regional stability and development.

5. Global Governance Concerns 

The absence of significant emerging economies from the G7 raises questions about the legitimacy of global governance structures. The expansion of the G7’s membership could enhance its credibility as a representative body, addressing worldwide challenges. 

Also Read: Historical Perspective & Factors Behind UK Pound’s Strength

Consequences of Exclusion for India 

Omission of India from G7 countries could have far-reaching consequences for its economic, security and political stability. Uncover the mystery of key effects India may face in the future.

1) Limited Influence 

India’s exclusion from the G7 means that it does not have a direct say in the decisions made by this group of major economies, which can affect Indian economic policies, trade agreements, and other regional issues. 

2) Trade and Economic Impact

Decisions and policies made by the G7 countries can have a significant impact on global trade and economic stability. India’s exclusion from these discussions may limit its ability to influence such decisions.

3) Access to Global Resources 

The G7 countries often have access to financial resources and development initiatives that can benefit member countries. India’s exclusion may limit its access to such resources.

Also Read: Why is Turkey a member of NATO?

Potential Pathways for India’s Engagement

In recent years, India has emerged as an economic giant in the South Asian region but its omission from G7 have raised multiple concerns. Inclusion of India would help to promote peace and stability in the region. There are several pathways that could lead to deeper engagement between India and the G7.

1) Expanded Membership 

The G7 could evolve into a more inclusive group by expanding its membership to reflect the changing global landscape. The process of expanded membership might involve inviting emerging economies like India to participate in certain discussions or as observers. By adopting a flexible approach, the G7 could benefit from a limitless range of perspectives while preserving its core functions. 

2) Specialised Partnerships

The G7 could establish specialised partnerships with emerging economies to address specific global challenges. India can play a pivotal role in joint initiatives related to climate change, health security, or technology advancement. Collective efforts on targeted issues could be helpful in promoting influence and stability in the whole region. 

3) Diplomatic Approach 

Diplomacy can create a potential pathway for the inclusion of India in G7 countries. Engaging in strategic diplomacy and coalitions with members of the Indian state could amplify the voice of G7 countries on global challenges.

4) Bilateral Engagements

G7 member states could engage in deeper bilateral dialogues with India to foster mutual understanding and further collaboration. Such engagements could play a significantly important role for broader involvement in G7 discussions. Bilateral partnerships could facilitate the exchange of expertise and priorities. 

5) Issue-based Participation

India could participate in G7 discussions on a case-by-case basis, particularly when its expertise is relevant to the topics being addressed. This approach could allow for meaningful contributions without committing to full membership. This flexible approach could provide a platform for India’s involvement while respecting its preferences for autonomy. 

Why is China not included in G7?

China is not included in the G7 for several key reasons. Firstly, the G7 was originally established as a forum for major Western industrialised democracies to discuss economic and financial matters. China, while a significant economic power, does not share the same political and economic systems as the G7 member nations. Its one-party communist state and state-led economic policies differ significantly from the democratic and market-oriented systems of G7 countries.

Secondly, China’s economic policies, including state intervention, subsidies, and trade practices, diverge from the liberal economic principles typically advocated by the G7 nations. These adversaries have led to trade disputes and tensions in international economic discussions. 

While cities like Beijing and Shanghai are recognized as advanced industrialised economies by institutions like the IMF and have achieved high-income status according to The World Bank, it’s crucial to acknowledge that China is not a monolithic entity. In terms of nominal GDP, China hovers just above the global average, with a nominal GDP per capita of approximately $4,166.8 USD according to CEIC data, which falls short of meeting the G7’s criteria.

In essence, the historical origins of the G7 as a Western-oriented forum during the 1970s also contribute to China’s exclusion, as it had limited engagement with the international community during that period, prioritising self-reliance instead.

Conclusion

India’s exclusion from the G7 reflects a complex interplay of historical, economic, and geopolitical factors. While it presents numerous challenges, it also encourages India to explore alternative avenues for international cooperation and influence, emphasising the importance of adapting to the changing dynamics of the global stage. On the other hand, India has their interests and priorities, taking precedence over inclusion in G7 countries.  

FAQs

What is the purpose of G7? 

The G7 unites the world’s leading economies with the aim of shaping global developments, addressing widespread and interconnected challenges, and responding to emerging global emergencies.

How successful is the G7?

G7 has a success rate of 76% with its past commitments. In the times of COVID-19, member states of G7 actively funded the vaccination program. Although, the success ratio can be improved by speeding up the efforts to fulfil its commitments about economic stability around the world. 

Is India part of G7 and G20? 

India is not a part of G7 as of now. On the other hand, India is one of the prominent members of G20. India has also hosted the summit of G7 this year, focusing on political and economic turmoil around the world and its solutions.  

Oleksandra Mamchii

Working as a academic lead at Best Diplomats.

Leave a Reply